The Fate of Extraordinary Aliens Under the Immigration Bill

The Washington

Post is worried about the future of the EB-1 green card for extraordinary

aliens. It’s the green card which allowed the likes of John Lennon and Albert

Einstein into the country, and is awarded to foreign-born VIPs wanting to live

and work in the US. Under the proposed immigration reform, the EB-1 could be

abolished, which would be a bad thing.

But there are two things to note, here, which the Washington Post doesn’t mention.

Firstly, although it’s true that some truly exceptional people do get the EB-1

green card every year, it’s also true that some really rather normal people

do as well. It’s one of those things which is largely self-selecting: if you’re

confident in your own abilities, and you have a good lawyer, then there’s a

good chance your EB-1 application will be successful even if you’re not "one

of a half-dozen people in this world who is up to the job of heading a division

of a multibillion-dollar behemoth," to use an example from the Post.

Secondly, as far as I can tell, even if the EB-1 program is abolished, the

O and P visas will not be. O and P visas are basically exactly the same as EB-1

green cards, except that they’re temporary rather than permanent. But they can

be renewed as many times as you like, so there’s really not a huge amount of


It would be sad were the EB-1 green card to be abolished, yes. But it really

wouldn’t be the end of the world.

(Via Borjas)

This entry was posted in immigration. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The Fate of Extraordinary Aliens Under the Immigration Bill

Comments are closed.