Are bankruptcy futures a good idea?

Alea, who broke

the news that the CFTC’s proposed CDS futures were being tranformed into bankruptcy

futures, has a provocative post up saying that this is actually a

good thing.

The CFTC was right to restrict the credit event to bankruptcy

only.

Otherwise sellers of protection would been in the same situation that an insurance

company having to pay up in full for a new house if there was a fire in the

attic.Not an attractive proposition.

Main benefit of the CME contract:

given that the recovery rate is fixed ,it will allow for discovery of the

implied hazard rate.This a Good Thing.

Sellers of protection are always in the position of that insurance

company, though – which is why they insist on getting a bond back in return

for paying out. It’s a bit like the insurance company saying that they’ll pay

out in full on the fire in the attic, but only if they get the house in return.

Now I’m unclear on how the new CFTC contract will work, but I do like the idea

that it will help create a very clear hazard rate, which is similar to the default

probability. I know that Jochen Andritzky at the IMF has a complicated formula

for deducing the default probability from the combination of CDS spreads and

bond spreads, but that doesn’t work when the CDS market simply dries up, as

it has done in the case of Ecuador.

My worry is

that bankruptcy futures will make workouts much messier, but Alea, by email,

reckons otherwise:

I don’t think it will complicate workouts because the event "bankruptcy"

itself terminates the contract and if one party has an incentive to game the

event, the other party, the seller of protection, has an incentive to counter

the gaming.

I’m looking forward to learning more about how these contracts work –

and seeing whether they take off. As Alea points

out, it’s been tried before, unsuccessfully.

This entry was posted in Econoblog. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Are bankruptcy futures a good idea?

  1. jck says:

    Felix

    I believe from reading the Enron emails that the CFTC actually was approached in 2000/2001 regarding the so-called bankruptcy swaps and they have had plenty of time to reflect on the issue of moral hazard that you rightly raise.

  2. dWj says:

    There are zero-recovery CDSs (though generally of low liquidity), and of course the spreads on them are wider; there’s no reason not to do a binary bet on whichever set of criteria you wish – without delivery of a reference obligation but the price is going to change.

    The average insurance company will insist that you actually own the house you’re insuring, and that you not overinsure (“I’ll pay twice the premium if you’ll pay double my losses”), largely, as I understand it, for moral hazard (and fraud) reasons; CDS prices are typically quoted on the assumption that neither party has substantial ability to actually cause the default to take place. You can buy protection on a bond you don’t own, and you can buy protection that will pay the full par value of a bond even if there is a nonzero recovery; there’s no moral hazard reason not to.

  3. A&F Bags Co. is a retailer selling casual clothing

    stores in 1998 to dress in the means of seven existence to 14 time old Olds. Men Polos Most of These teams have a very robust, but with a completely new idea of casual wear that focus on casual, accessories and delicate worry food at a sink detriment than the brand cheap abercrombie fitch.

    Until 1960 was sited in 1992 with a gentle handle to 22. Meeting not only clothes, but other clothing brand Abercrombie”in 22 to 35 years of age to customers. One of sophistication. ‘Hollister, another clothing make Abercrombie targets 14 to 18 days, students in California relaxed style.”Offer Hollister on method and Canada. Abercrombie & Fitch Women Gilly Hicks is another subsidiary of abercrombie womens jeans & Pants offers robes and underwear for women.Abercrombie & Fitch Abercrombie & Fitch is a registered imprint of the oldest names in the rage trade Abercrombie & Fitch. After a decline in venture, Abercrombie & Fitch was founded in 1892 by David Abercrombie. in 1900 and was connected by Ezra Fitch to give it its current name of Abercrombie & Fitch. He became notorious for sportswear and high value enduring and has been known for it’s stuffed and prominent clients. People like Teddy Roosevelt, hunting utensils and clothing was equipped by Abercrombie & Fitch.Abercrombie clothes abercrombie mens jeans was known for its reliability and durability.

  4. A&F Bags Co. is a retailer selling casual clothing

    stores in 1998 to dress in the means of seven existence to 14 time old Olds. Men Polos Most of These teams have a very robust, but with a completely new idea of casual wear that focus on casual, accessories and delicate worry food at a sink detriment than the brand cheap abercrombie fitch.

    Until 1960 was sited in 1992 with a gentle handle to 22. Meeting not only clothes, but other clothing brand Abercrombie”in 22 to 35 years of age to customers. One of sophistication. ‘Hollister, another clothing make Abercrombie targets 14 to 18 days, students in California relaxed style.”Offer Hollister on method and Canada. Abercrombie & Fitch Women Gilly Hicks is another subsidiary of abercrombie womens jeans & Pants offers robes and underwear for women.Abercrombie & Fitch Abercrombie & Fitch is a registered imprint of the oldest names in the rage trade Abercrombie & Fitch. After a decline in venture, Abercrombie & Fitch was founded in 1892 by David Abercrombie. in 1900 and was connected by Ezra Fitch to give it its current name of Abercrombie & Fitch. He became notorious for sportswear and high value enduring and has been known for it’s stuffed and prominent clients. People like Teddy Roosevelt, hunting utensils and clothing was equipped by Abercrombie & Fitch.Abercrombie clothes abercrombie mens jeans was known for its reliability and durability.

  5. s says:

    Thanks for sharing the nice post with me, an

    ,

    girl who firmly follows the fashion trend,

    It really brings me some fresh feelings with addtional insights into today’s world.

Comments are closed.