Are Uninsured Bank Depositors in Danger?

One of Dan Colarusso’s favorite bloggers, Hugo Lindgren, picks up on the latest weekly newsletter

from Christopher Wood:

It is even more amazing that Obama does not understand the political appeal of the nationalization option. Maybe the so-called liberal Democrats are worried about adopting such a seemingly socialistic solution … but despite this latest setback nationalization of the banks is coming sooner or later because the realities of the situation will demand it. The result will be shareholders wiped out and bondholders forced to take debt-for-equity swaps, if not hopefully depositors.

"Seemingly" socialistic is right: even the AEI’s John Makin — no socialist he — is quoted in the NYT today as saying that “the lesson from Japan in the 1990s was that they should have stepped up and nationalized the banks.”

But what about those depositors? Paul Kedrosky is shaken by Wood’s conclusion:

I was with him right up until the last bit, but am I just sleep-deprived, or is Chris really arguing that there is a potential future where some U.S. bank depositors become forced equity holders?

It’s worth remembering that depositors are unsecured creditors of any bank; usually, indeed, they’re by far the largest class of unsecured creditors. Paul seems to think that they are, or should be, senior to bondholders: that might be true de facto, but it’s certainly not true de jure. *

It’s this very fact which led to the implementation of deposit insurance in most major banking systems; at this point we’re up to $250,000 in the US, which is a lot of money. If a bank fails, the FDIC will ensure that its depositors are paid out in full up to $250,000 each. But this is an insurance policy: it’s not a declaration that deposits are in any way senior to bonds. And if bondholders are forced to take a haircut, then by the principle of pari passu there’s a strong case to be made that depositors should take a haircut too.

In practice, this will apply only to uninsured depositors, of course. I’ve got a call in to the FDIC to find out what the total amount of uninsured deposits in the US banking system is, but given that total deposits as of June last year totaled over $7 trillion, it’s bound to be a large number.

(Update: Found it, at the top of page 17 of this pdf. Total domestic deposits at FDIC-insured institutions are $7.23 trillion, and total insured deposits are $4.54 trillion. Which means that total uninsured deposits are $2.68 trillion. That’s huge.)

The Washington Mutual precedent is interesting: the bank’s uninsured depositors remained whole even as its bondholders were largely wiped out. For the time being, I suspect that the FDIC will continue to try to make the distinction, and will put much more effort into protecting depositors than protecting bondholders. But as we’ve learned many times in recent history, it’s very dangerous to rely on precedent in such situations. And so there’s a good chance that at some point, a US bank failure is indeed going to result in losses for uninsured depositors. After all, that’s what always used to happen.

*Update 2: John Hempton calls to inform me that depositors actually are legally senior to unsecured bondholders, although they’re junior to secured bondholders.

This entry was posted in banking. Bookmark the permalink.

51 Responses to Are Uninsured Bank Depositors in Danger?

  1. fgdf says:

    The world’s top luxury brands.sexy,gorgeous,fun.

    for a woman,Exudes a fatal attraction

    Noble,Elegant,Charming

    all in there.

  2. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | WEB OF DEBT BLOG

  3. Pingback: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors » Counterpunch: Tells the Facts, Names the Names

  4. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors - LA Progressive

  5. Pingback: US Plans to Seize FDIC Insured Bank Deposits in Next Crisis « Beaver County Blue

  6. Pingback: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors – CounterPunch 28 March 2013 | LightFlicks

  7. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | Counter Information

  8. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors by Ellen Brown | Dandelion Salad

  9. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned For US and UK Depositors

  10. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | Conspiracyanalyst's Thoughts and Research

  11. Pingback: Max Keiser critique on Georgie Osborne, Cameron and Glegg – direct link, video and text |

  12. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors |

  13. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | EPAM

  14. Pingback: Gun Control Not on Table, Guantanamo Abuse, Banksters Can Take Your Savings » Clearing the FOG Radio

  15. Pingback: Liberty 03/29/2013 (p.m.) | Liberty in the Breach

  16. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors : Sierra Voices

  17. Pingback: Could Your Money be Confiscated Like Cyprus, Apparently So « DarkGovernment

  18. Pingback: Think Your Money is Safe? Think Again: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors ~ Alternet | Stop Making Sense

  19. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | Thought FTW

  20. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | Crisis and Revolt

  21. Pingback: THE CONFISCATION SCHEME PLANNED FOR UNITED STATES AND BRITAIN DEPOSITERS | sreaves32

  22. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors — State of Globe

  23. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors - BSNEWS

  24. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | Foreclosure Fraud - Fighting Foreclosure Fraud by Sharing the Knowledge

  25. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors - ALIPAC

  26. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors — Financial Press

  27. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | Spirit In Action

  28. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors - | Intellihub.com

  29. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | NO LIES RADIO

  30. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors

  31. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | My Light Warrior "OPPT-IN"

  32. Pingback: Asalto a los ahorros: los depósitos convertidos en acciones bancarias | noticias de abajo

  33. Pingback: Think Your Money is Safe? Think Again: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | 2012: What's the 'real' truth?

  34. ouchosparks says:

    Sure, there’s the law (and we know what that is worth). Then there is the reality of power relations, privileges and class. Creditors rule, to put it bluntly. Depositors are just scum..they may be large in number, but have little to no power.

  35. Pingback: It Can Happen Here - BSNEWS

  36. Pingback: Cyprus As Canary – It Can Happen Here: The Bank Currency Confiscation Scheme for US & UK Depositors | The Oldspeak Journal

  37. Pingback: Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | The Big Picture

  38. Pingback: CRUMMY BANKSTERS’ PLAN IN PLACE FOR AMERICA! | as the world crumbles

  39. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Bank Confiscation Scheme for US and UK Depositors | Orwellwasright's Weblog

  40. Pingback: It can happen here: The confiscation scheme planned for US and UK depositors | Intrepid Report.com

  41. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors By Ellen Brown | Sailan Muslim - The Online Resource for Sri Lanka Muslims

  42. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Banks Deposit Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors

  43. Pingback: - The News They Don't Want You to Know

  44. Pingback: Think Your Money is Safe? Think Again: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors - The News They Don't Want You to Know

  45. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | Collapsing Into Consciousness

  46. Pingback: Virtually theft: US and UK confiscation schemes | Ramy Abdeljabbar's Palestine and World News

  47. Pingback: It Can Happen Here: Cyprus-Style Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors | LeakSource

  48. Pingback: Cyrano's Journal Today » It Can Happen Here: The Confiscation Scheme Planned for US and UK Depositors

  49. Pingback: Bankers will steal your money and do it LEGALLY and there’s FKN nothing you can do about it after it happens. BUT YOU CAN AVOID THIS BY TAKING YOUR MONEY OUT of there Banks NOW as fast as you can get it out. Because when all people realize this dist

  50. Pingback: Bankers will steal your money and do it LEGALLY and there’s FKN nothing you can do about it after it happens. BUT YOU CAN AVOID THIS BY TAKING YOUR MONEY OUT of there Banks NOW as fast as you can get it out. Because when all people realize this dist

Comments are closed.