Ecuador: Is the government manipulating the bond market?

Are you still reading the EIU report on Ecuador from last Friday? Silly. Don't believe for a second that anything in Ecuador can remain germane through a whole weekend. (For what it's worth, the EIU has Ecuador on a CCC rating with negative outlook, and says that "the Correa government seems determined to forge ahead" with a debt default.)

In any case, the outlook seemed to brighten on Monday, at least according to Felipe Hernandez of Deutsche Bank, who put out a note on the subject of a radio interview given by finance minister Ricard Patiño: apparently he said that "defaulting on external debt is not the policy of the government." At the same time, there were rumours in the market that Ecuador had already wired its February 15 coupon payment to Euroclear.

What's going on? Patiño seems to be in no mood to clarify anything: in the same interview, he said that parts of Ecuador's external debt is illegitimate and should not be paid. Says Deutsche's Hernandez:

Minister Patiño reiterated official plans to audit the outstanding external debt to decide which is the illegitimate debt and that the illegitimate debt would not be paid. Plans to audit the external debt are likely to take at least a couple of months. Without the results from this, we do not expect the government making any restructuring proposal or any decision on the debt plans. In line with this, one should expect the government to meet debt payments at least until it has the results from the audit and a clear debt restructuring proposal. This does not necessarily rule out the possibility of some delays in the debt payments. According to Minister Patiño he expects to have a debt restructuring proposal ready some time in H1-07.

This morning, Walter Molano of BCP securities put out his own note, saying, essentially, that if you think you understand why the market in Ecuadorean bonds is moving, you're probably wrong:

The aggressive statements issued by members of the Correa Administration are an overt attempt to push down Ecuadorian bond prices. At the same time, the close association between Ecuador and Venezuela, and the Chavez Administration’s growing propensity for market manipulation, suggests that the recent statements about the debt instruments were accompanied by surreptitious buyback operations. A game is, definitely, afoot in Ecuador. Government officials are playing a high stakes game of poker, and they are bluffing their way in order to bolster their bargaining positions. Nevertheless, the game is complex, and there are a lot of seasoned players on the table. Therefore, one should be careful. As the old adage goes, “If you can't spot the patsy at the poker table, then you are the patsy.”

The idea of Ecuadorean shenanigans is hardly new. Two months ago I wrote this:

If I was a devious Ecuadorean finance minister, I might even start buying up credit protection right now – and lots of it. CDS spreads would rise, and eventually arbitrageurs would drive down the price of the bonds, perhaps to levels less than say 80 cents on the dollar, where I could start buying my own debt back cheap without having to go through a formal restructuring.

Not much later, Ecuadorean bonds dropped significantly below 80 cents on the dollar; indeed, at one point, they were even below 70 cents. Did Ecuador buy back any bonds while they were down there? I have no idea. But it would be much easier and cheaper than going through a formal debt restructuring.

Posted by Felix at 12:23 EST

Comments

ugg boots sale at a time when large heat has set off a winter 08/09 to Ewha.Outlines the warm wool winter fashion degree to wool crocheted wool ugg boots uk to join after the body does not stimulate your skin soft, soft comfort UP. Fashion can not without
ugg boots presence in Winter.and ugg boots have many series.such as:
ugg classic
UGG Bailey Button boots
UGG Button
UGG Bailey
ugg nightfall
ugg kids

Posted by: uggboots at 21:48 EST, December 01, 2009

ugg boots sale -The best Christmas Presents for Lover & Family
Christmas is coming,it's great time to shop Genuine UGG Boots as Christmas gifts to keep your lover & family warm and cozy.
Love UGGs,Love UGG Boots UK ale is fashionable & warm and comfortable.
Hot Shoes- Cheap Jordan shoes and Gucci shoes are on sale-Free shipping.
Welcome to visit the hothotuggs.com, you may will have unexpected surprises!
bailey button ugg boots、
tall ugg boots,
cardy ugg boots,
UGG Sundance Boots.

Posted by: uggs at 3:41 EST, December 08, 2009

we know winter is very cold,we began ugg boots sale,the boots were ugg boots uk,do you Want to buy a pair of new ugg boots? We professional supply
UGG Bailey Button boots,
UGG Classic Cardy,
Bailey Button,
UGG Classic Short,
UGG Classic Tall,
UGG Kids online,this winter the best way to keep your feet warm is to get a pair of ugg Boots.

Posted by: uggboots at 20:54 EST, December 10, 2009

uggs outlet
uggs on sale

Ugg Upside
Ugg Ultra Short Le
Ugg Mini
Ugg Sunburst Tall
Ugg Whitely Boots
Ugg Amelie
Ugg Short
Ugg Tall
Ugg Nightfall
Ugg Classic
Ugg Cardy
Ugg Crochet
Ugg Ultra Short
Ugg Tasman

Posted by: uggs outlet at 1:48 EST, January 08, 2010

so nice post.CHI flat iron by Farouk system. Direct from the manufacturer,
this genuine Chi ceramic iron comes with valid.

Posted by: Chi Hair Straightener on sale at 3:45 EST, January 15, 2010

wow!!!
what a nice place to visit..
great location to have a vacation..
thanks for sharing it..
love it.uggs outlet

Posted by: cheap uggs at 21:23 EST, January 25, 2010

Posted by: ugg boots at 12:11 EST, February 05, 2010

MTS Converter,

Posted by: herry at 3:05 EST, February 24, 2010

"The K-12 educational establishment still acts as though we were back in the 1950s--as if women could be nurses, secretaries, waitresses, laundresses, and teachers and nothing else--and so you didn't have to pay teachers a reasonable wage to get high quality."MTS Converter,

Posted by: herry at 3:07 EST, February 24, 2010